Self-Defense Claim Collapses In Court
A Wyoming woman who drew a pistol after being shoved during a street confrontation has resolved her felony case with a no-contest plea to misdemeanor reckless endangerment, avoiding the 15-year prison exposure she faced under the original charge.
Snapshot
Rihanna Kelver, 28, of Laramie, pulled and racked a handgun after a man shoved her to the ground following a confrontation outside a bar in September. A judge had already ruled Wyoming's stand-your-ground law didn't protect her because the threat wasn't apparent, and Bearing Arms reports Kelver now faces sentencing in early December under a plea deal that could keep the charge off her record entirely.
Key points
- The incident: Kelver confronted a group of men after hearing what she said was a slur, was shoved and fell, then drew and pointed her gun without firing before the men walked away, according to Bearing Arms.
- The legal ruling: The judge overseeing the case found Wyoming's stand-your-ground statute didn't apply because prosecutors and the court didn't believe Kelver's life was in danger at the time.
- The plea deal: Felony charges carrying up to 15 years were dropped in exchange for a no-contest plea to reckless endangering, with Bearing Arms noting Cowboy State Daily reported the charge could be expunged if she completes probation.
- Kelver's position: She maintains she's innocent and broke no Wyoming statute, calling the outcome "not justice" in a Facebook post, even while accepting the deal.
- Second Amendment outcome: The plea preserves her gun rights and spares her significant prison time, which Bearing Arms columnist Cam Edwards called a reasonable result given the alternative.
Quick take
Edwards argues this case is a useful reminder for armed citizens: a shove or an insult, however ugly, isn't automatically a deadly threat, and stand-your-ground laws don't erase the need for a reasonable belief that your life is at risk. He says Kelver made a serious mistake that night, even as he welcomes an outcome that keeps her out of prison and off the prohibited-persons list.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com