ATF's Destruction of Pardoned Pastor's Guns Draws FOIA Probe
A presidential pardon can clear a man's record, but it can't un-destroy his guns. That's the situation Oklahoma pastor Russell Fincher says he's facing after ATF Director Robert Cekada told him the agency destroyed every one of his seized firearms, even though Fincher was later pardoned by President Trump.
Snapshot
Bearing Arms reports that Fincher, convicted on a gun charge, had more than 50 personal firearms seized by the ATF, including a Wilson Combat pistol, five Glocks and a valuable pre-ban Polytech AK underfolder. He now says he can't get straight answers on when or whether the destruction actually happened.
Key points
- The collection: ATF seized over 50 firearms from Fincher, among them a Wilson Combat, five Glocks and a mint pre-ban Polytech milled underfolder AK worth thousands.
- Director's claim: Cekada told Fincher this week that ATF staff destroyed all of his firearms, even after Trump's pardon.
- Fincher's doubt: He's asking the ATF to "show me the evidence" and the video of the destruction, saying he trusts Cekada but not necessarily "his people."
- Murky timeline: Accounts conflict over whether the guns were destroyed in June or August 2026, and whether the process was even recorded.
- SAF steps in: The Second Amendment Foundation has filed a FOIA request seeking records on the destruction.
Quick take
Bearing Arms' Tom Knighton argues the real failure here isn't that Fincher lost the right to own these guns, it's that the ATF was ever in a position to destroy his property instead of letting him transfer it to someone else who could lawfully hold it. He says heads should roll if the FOIA records confirm there was no good reason the guns couldn't have been saved for a situation exactly like this one.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com