Why Gun Owners Should Fear Preemption Repeals, Not Just New Bans
Everyone's watching for the next bill that bans something. William Kirk of Washington Gun Law says the bigger threat might be a bill that removes something: your state's firearm preemption law.
Snapshot
Kirk argues that after blue-wave midterm wins, gun-rights advocates should watch for quiet efforts to repeal state preemption statutes, not just new restrictions. These laws keep firearm regulation at the state level and block cities or counties from passing tighter rules. Kirk warns that repealing them is a one-line bill that could do more damage than any single gun-control measure.
Key points
- What preemption does: Kirk explains these statutes, on the books in 40 of 50 states, give state legislatures exclusive authority over firearm regulation, blocking local governments from adding their own rules.
- Washington's law as the model: He cites Washington's 1983 preemption statute (RCW 9.41.290), strengthened in 1985, as the template Florida copied in 1987.
- Bass v. Edmonds: Kirk points to this case, where Edmonds' local safe-storage ordinance lost unanimously at the court of appeals and 9-0 at the Washington Supreme Court, as proof these laws carry real legal weight.
- Repeal is easy, fallout is not: He says scrapping preemption takes almost no legislative effort, but would create a patchwork where gun laws change block by block, exactly like the lawsuit-heavy landscape in California and Illinois cases such as Vermont v. Cook County.
- Resources get stretched thin: Kirk warns that more jurisdictions writing their own gun laws means more litigation than Second Amendment groups can realistically fight.
Quick take
Kirk's bigger point: don't just read bill titles, read what's being repealed. A one-line statute change can do more damage than a flashy new ban, and it's easy to miss if you're not paying attention to your state's legislative session.
Watch the full video: Washington Gun Law