Florida AG Won't Defend Bump-Stock Ban, But Warns It's No Green Light
Florida's attorney general just said the quiet part out loud: the state's 2018 bump-stock ban is written so broadly it may be unconstitutional, and his office will stop defending convictions under it. In a video from Colion Noir, he walks through how that opinion came about and why gun owners shouldn't assume it's a green light yet.
Snapshot
Colion Noir breaks down a new Florida AG legal opinion that calls the state's bump-stock law unconstitutional under the Second Amendment because its language sweeps in trigger enhancements beyond bump stocks, including force reset triggers. He ties the opinion directly to Rare Breed Triggers' 2024 federal court win and argues Florida is increasingly leading on Second Amendment protections.
Key points
- The law: Florida's 2018 ban, signed by then-Governor Rick Scott, prohibits any device that increases a firearm's rate of fire, carrying up to five years in prison.
- The opinion: The attorney general says the statute is "overly broad," calls it unconstitutional under the Second Amendment, and states his office won't defend convictions under it going forward.
- The connection: Noir notes the opinion's first footnote cites the 2024 Texas ruling that Rare Breed Triggers' FRT-15 isn't a machine gun, a case Rare Breed and the National Association for Gun Rights won after the DOJ sued and later settled in 2025.
- The players: Noir says Rare Breed funded the Florida legal effort behind this opinion, bringing in the same attorneys who beat the federal government.
- The catch: Noir warns there's a specific disclaimer on the AG's own website that determines whether this opinion actually shields anyone right now, which he covers in a separate full-length video.
Quick take
This is a real crack in a state gun law, not just another federal trigger ruling, and it's worth watching closely if you're in Florida. But Noir's own caution matters: an AG opinion isn't a repeal, and until that fine print gets sorted out, don't assume you're in the clear.
Watch the full video: Colion Noir